Army says it may detonate five tons of unstable lead azide in Iowa without a permit
Justice Department tells appeals court its pause does not bar emergency authority, stockpile degraded until only choices were a controlled blast or an uncontrolled one
Images
A sign sits on top of a building at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant on Thursday in Middletown, Iowa.
cnn.com
The US Army says it may detonate nearly five tons of unstable lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown as early as this week — even though a federal appeals court has paused the permit that would allow it. In a filing on Saturday, the Justice Department told the court that its order "does not enjoin or otherwise prohibit the Army from acting under a separate legal authority," laying the groundwork for an emergency exemption that would let the detonation proceed without any permit at all.
The material at issue is roughly 70 drums of lead azide, a compound used to detonate munitions, which the Army discovered had been degrading during "routine stockpile surveillance" in March. An Army FAQ distributed to the Middletown community last month described the degraded lead azide as "extremely unstable and sensitive to even slight friction or movement," and stated that packing and transporting it "poses an unacceptable risk of accidental detonation to personnel handling and transporting as well as to the public." After consulting the EPA, experts and the community, officials concluded that a controlled detonation in the open posed the lowest risk to the surrounding area.
The detonation was originally scheduled for Friday morning, then moved to Monday — a date Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle described as the "latest possible moment prior to a forecasted temperature drop, which would risk further destabilization of the material." The Army says the material could explode on its own as temperatures fall. In other words, the stockpile was allowed to sit until the only remaining options were a blast the Army controls or a blast it does not.
A federal appeals court paused the EPA permit on Thursday after environmental groups sued. Rachel Rintelmann, a managing attorney at Earthjustice, which represents the groups, said the Justice Department has "laid the groundwork for a possible detonation without a permit, which would effectively bypass judicial process and review." The Justice Department's own filing framed the stakes: "The real choice, in other words, is not between a detonation and no detonation. It is between a planned and mitigated detonation and an unplanned and unmitigated explosion."
The plan has drawn heavy pushback from Iowans, environmental advocates and politicians. Opponents worry the plume could spread toxic lead dust over vast stretches of rural Iowa, the Mississippi River and potentially part of western Illinois. Lead dust is unhealthy at any level and especially dangerous to children. Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds activated a state emergency operations center on Friday, officials in nearby Illinois are warning their residents about dust drifting across the state line, and the FAA has restricted flights over Middletown from Monday through Wednesday.
The City of Fort Madison was told the detonation will most likely occur Monday or Tuesday; if it does not happen this week, "another time will need to be arranged with additional planning." Each week of delay, by the Army's own account, degrades the material further — while the cheapest disposal method on the table remains the one that puts the plume over someone else's land.
The FAA's flight restriction over Middletown expires Wednesday.