Trump DOJ backs Biden bid to bury $1 billion solar fraud claim
Investors say ACS-linked firms lied to collect $275 million grant for failed Nevada plant, Crescent Dunes carried a $737 million guarantee and sold for $7 million
Images
Investor alleges $275M fraud in bankrupt Obama-era solar plant grant
foxnews.com
Wide aerial view of the Crescent Dunes solar power plant in the Nevada desert, showing thousands of mirrors arranged in a massive circle around a brightly glowing central tower.
foxnews.com
Infographic showing SolarReserve, ACS Group/Cobra, Banco Santander, CMB investors, the Department of Energy and U.S. Treasury, with funding connections to the Crescent Dunes solar plant.
foxnews.com
Portrait of Pat Hogan, CEO of CMB Regional Centers, wearing a dark suit and light blue tie against a dark background.
foxnews.com
Split image showing the Crescent Dunes solar tower surrounded by mirrors in Nevada on the left and the U.S. Treasury Department building in Washington, D.C., on the right.
foxnews.com
Two days after President Trump's reelection in November 2024, the Biden Justice Department moved to shut down a whistleblower suit that could recover up to $1 billion for taxpayers. Trump's own department has since defended that dismissal before a federal appeals court.
The suit concerns Crescent Dunes, a government-backed solar plant near Tonopah, Nevada, that began operating in 2015 and has since passed through two bankruptcies. Its investors — a group called CMB, headed by Pat Hogan, that provided $90 million of the project's private financing — filed it in 2020 under the False Claims Act. They allege the plant's former owner and companies linked to the Spanish construction giant ACS misled federal officials to secure a $275 million Treasury grant; SolarReserve, ACS Group's Cobra and Banco Santander were the original participants. The investors say the companies called the plant ready for use even though a molten-salt-tank failure had shut it down for months.
The stakes are large for a program already wound down. Crescent Dunes carried a $737 million Department of Energy loan guarantee on top of roughly $275.6 million in Treasury grant awards. Under the False Claims Act, a court can award up to three times the government's proven losses, plus penalties. Hogan, chief executive of CMB Regional Centers, puts the potential recovery at a billion dollars.
The department's stated reason for wanting out: pursuing the case would burden federal agencies. Hogan says he has asked Trump's Justice Department to request that the court reopen the matter, and has received no commitment. "It makes no sense," he told Fox News. "The real problem here is, why isn't the government asking for this?"
That posture accompanies an administration that has made fraud enforcement a central claim — cash rewards for whistleblowers who expose wrongdoing, a White House map tracking billions in suspected fraud, and a Justice Department tax crackdown listing 76 defendants and nearly $500 million in alleged losses.
Crescent Dunes was built as an emerging-technology showcase: thousands of mirrors concentrating sunlight onto a towering receiver, heating molten salt that could keep generating electricity after sunset. It was plagued by engineering failures and repeated shutdowns, and regulators had let it kill thousands of birds a year, a Fox News investigation found.
Hogan's appeal is pending. The plant sold for $7 million in July.