French police who open fire presumed to have acted lawfully
Senate passes law 205 to 110 with National Rally support, left prepares Constitutional Council challenge
Images
LUCAS BARIOULET/AFP
zerohedge.com
205 senators voted in favour of the text (illustrative photo). LP/Arnaud Journois
zerohedge.com
A protester holds a banner reading "Justice for Nahel" as cars burn in the street in the Paris suburb of Nanterre, France, on June 29, 2023, at the end of a commemoration march for a 17-year-old driver who was shot dead by a police officer two days earlier.Bertrand Guay/AFP via Getty Images
zerohedge.com
France's parliament has given final approval to a law under which police officers and gendarmes who fire their weapons are presumed to have acted lawfully. The Senate passed the text 205 votes to 110 on November 20, in wording identical to the National Assembly's July vote, which makes the law final. Opponents have branded it a licence to kill.
The law adds a single paragraph to Article L. 435-1 of the Internal Security Code, which since 2017 has set out the cases in which police may open fire. Officers who use their weapons are presumed to have acted within those cases, "in accordance with the conditions of absolute necessity and strict proportionality" — a presumption that "may, at any time, be overturned by any contrary evidence". The right-wing and centrist majority carried the text alongside Marine Le Pen's National Rally; the left voted against, and senators from Emmanuel Macron's own group abstained on a law his government had written.
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez says the change ends the automatic placement in custody of officers who have fired, who will instead be questioned voluntarily where appropriate. "What we wanted to do is simply not to suspect them ex ante," he told senators. Who produces the contrary evidence is the question the opposition raises. "The burden will be insurmountable for the victim," said the Socialist senator Marie-Pierre de la Gontrie, noting that families of the dead have no investigative powers of their own. The Communist senator Ian Brossat put it more bluntly: "You are telling officers: 'When in doubt, shoot, the law will be on your side!'" The Human Rights League warns the presumption could block investigations after a driver refuses to stop or during crowd control at protests.
The Senate rapporteur, Lauriane Josende of the Republicans, answers that the presumption in no way prevents an investigation, and that the left confuses presumption with custody. Her committee's figures show police shots in operations nearly halved between 2017 and 2025, from 338 to 176, with gendarmes averaging 63 uses of their weapons a year. Of 14 investigations into fatal police shootings in 2024, judges found the use of force legitimate in 12, with two still open. Police logged 6,625 physical assaults in 2024, 1,289 of them with a weapon, and nearly 3,200 gendarmes have been injured in attacks so far this year, up a quarter on the same period last year.
The 2017 law extended to police the gendarmes' broader power to fire on vehicles whose drivers refuse to stop, and critics tie it to deaths at traffic stops. In June 2023 the 17-year-old Nahel Merzouk was shot at close range through a car window in Nanterre, setting off a week of riots; the case against the officer is still open. The left says fatal police shootings have multiplied five-fold in recent years, a figure Nuñez disputes. Left-wing senators now plan to take the law to the Constitutional Council. The next officer who fires will be presumed to have acted lawfully.