Scottish NHS opens over 5 000 serious safety reviews since 2020
Figures surface through Labour's written question rather than government publication, each review ends in learning for the board that conducted it
Images
standard.co.uk
standard.co.uk
Scotland's health boards have opened more than 5,000 reviews of serious safety incidents since January 2020, according to figures published in response to a written parliamentary question from Scottish Labour. At least 4,898 reviews were carried out in the country's territorial health boards between January 2020 and September this year, with at least 303 more recorded in the special boards that include NHS24, the State Hospital at Carstairs and the ambulance service. The government did not publish the total on its own initiative; it counted it because an opposition politician asked for it.
A review begins when an event "could have caused or did cause" harm to a patient, staff member or visitor — a definition that sweeps in not only injuries but the near misses. The stated purpose, in the Scottish government's own description, is to find out what happened and identify learning that reduces the risk of the same thing happening again.
Jackie Baillie, deputy leader of Scottish Labour, called the figures "shocking and highly alarming". "Patient safety must be absolutely paramount in our NHS, but it is clear that on far too many occasions that has sadly not been the case," she said, noting that such incidents can end in permanent injury or the loss of a loved one. Frontline staff, she added, work under immense pressure without being given the support needed to ease it.
Miles Briggs, health spokesman for the Scottish Conservatives, put the same numbers to harder use: Scottish patients are "paying a heavy price for SNP incompetence," with corridor care "becoming the shocking norm" in a health service he called appalling, presided over by John Swinney and successive SNP health secretaries who have failed to get a grip on what he described as a permanent crisis.
The Scottish government's response to the figures is a list of the institutions it has built around failure. Patient safety "must always be paramount," a spokesperson said, pointing to an independent patient safety commissioner established by the government, a Scottish Patient Safety Programme running since 2008, and regular inspections by Healthcare Improvement Scotland, the independent health inspectorate. The NHS "provides excellent care for the vast majority of patients," and on the rare occasions it falls short, "health boards must listen and take action to improve."
The structure of the answer is the story. The board that treats the patient also investigates what happened, writes the account of it, and files the result as learning to be applied across the same service. Reviews, the spokesperson said, must be done transparently with families, and ministers are clear any learning must be applied across the entirety of the NHS — for the benefit of patients, carers and staff.
What the machinery produces is documented. At least one review has opened for every day the Scottish Patient Safety Programme has existed since the question was first asked.
The programme has been running since 2008. The five thousand reviews opened since January 2020 are the written record of what it has learned.