World

US Congress office warns Aukus submarine sales would thin own fleet

CBO finds shipyards build Virginia-class boats at 1.13 a year against a needed 2.33, Navy plan does not count the boats promised to Canberra

Images

A Virginia-class nuclear-powered attack submarine. The US has agreed to agreed to sell between three and five of the submarines to Australia, beginning in 2032, under Aukus. Photograph: Richard Wainwright/AAP A Virginia-class nuclear-powered attack submarine. The US has agreed to agreed to sell between three and five of the submarines to Australia, beginning in 2032, under Aukus. Photograph: Richard Wainwright/AAP theguardian.com

The Congressional Budget Office has cautioned that supplying nuclear-powered submarines to Australia under Aukus would diminish the US Navy's own attack-submarine fleet for "many years." The US shipyards building Virginia-class boats currently produce them at a rate of 1.13 a year. The Navy needs two a year for its own requirements; it would need 2.33 a year to have spare boats to transfer. Under "Pillar One" of Aukus, Washington has agreed to sell Australia between three and five in-service Virginia-class submarines, with transfers scheduled to begin in 2032.

The CBO's analysis, prepared for Congress, found the submarine industrial base is already struggling to meet the Navy's demand, and that increasing production to replace the sold boats would compound the strain on shipyards. The Navy's own shipbuilding plan does not account for the transfers at all — a footnote concedes that handing any Virginia-class boat to Australia "has not been factored into the plan." Building a submarine took five to six years in the 2000s; current schedules run ten to eleven years, with Virginia-class boats previously delayed between 24 and 36 months.

The report also questioned the deterrence logic. Would China be less deterred if the United States reduced its attack-submarine numbers to help Australia build its own force? Australian boats would be based in the Western Pacific and could respond faster to a conflict over Taiwan or the South China Sea — but Australia controls them. Defence minister Richard Marles said in 2023 that Australia makes no promises to deploy its submarines in support of any US conflict with China, and that any future boats would be "under the complete control of the Australian government of the day."

US legislation governing Aukus requires the president to ensure that losing a submarine from US service will not degrade the American fleet — a requirement the CBO's own arithmetic suggests cannot be met at current production rates. Canberra, meanwhile, has already paid into the arrangement.

The commitment Australia bought and the capability America can deliver are separated by more than a decade of backlog and a production gap the report's own numbers make plain. The Navy's shipbuilding plan will not include the boats it has promised to sell.