Technology

Met officers photograph Londoners without consent in phone facial recognition pilot

100 officers check faces against one million custody images while the promised government watchdog does not yet exist

Images

One hundred officers are involved in the six-month pilot (Getty/iStock) One hundred officers are involved in the six-month pilot (Getty/iStock) Getty/iStock
The government has promised tougher protections to ensure police use of facial recognition technology is ’fair, safe and proportionate’ (PA) The government has promised tougher protections to ensure police use of facial recognition technology is ’fair, safe and proportionate’ (PA) independent.co.uk
standard.co.uk
standard.co.uk
standard.co.uk

Metropolitan Police officers in London can now photograph people on the street and run facial recognition against a database of about one million custody images, without consent, under a six-month pilot launched November 17. Around 100 officers carry the app on Met-issued phones.

Scotland Yard says officers must tell people before taking the photo but do not need their permission, and will not use force if someone covers their face. Commander Nick John said the app helps identify people faster: "If a person is not willing or able to confirm their identification, or we believe they might not be telling the truth, then the officer can take a photo on their Met-issued phone, upload it into the app, and the app will search against our custody images." He insisted officers would not be "going around London taking photos of people from a distance who aren't suspected of being involved in any offending." In the pilot's first 24 hours, officers uploaded 15 photos — which John called "more than I was expecting."

The technology, Operator-Initiated Facial Recognition, moves biometric identification out of the fixed camera vans deployed at events like this year's Notting Hill Carnival and into individual officers' pockets. Until now, live facial recognition required infrastructure; the new version requires only a phone and an officer's suspicion.

Critics say the combination inherits the worst of both precedents. Akiko Hart, director of the civil liberties group Liberty, warned that the pilot "combines all of the problems of stop-and-search with those of facial recognition," and cited existing evidence that such devices are used disproportionately against marginalised communities. Habib Kadiri of StopWatch UK said no one has demonstrated that inherent racial bias in facial recognition has been mitigated in any form.

The Met says the pilot will not be used on under-18s, and the wider programme will exclude under-13s. The trial began weeks after the government promised tougher protections to ensure police use of facial recognition is "fair, safe and proportionate," including a new watchdog with powers to ban forces that fail standards. That watchdog does not yet exist; the app already does — and its legal basis is a six-month "pilot" rather than an act of Parliament.