Maine parents sue town over autistic daughter's metal rooster statues
Ogunquit fines the 6-foot birds as restaurant advertising while lobster buoys and tiki statues go unticketed, disability variance demanded a railing and the family chained them to posts instead
David and Sara LeBlanc have sued the town of Ogunquit, Maine, in federal court over a sign code the town used to fine them repeatedly for the roughly six-foot metal rooster statues displayed outside their home. The statues, the couple say, are ornaments kept for their autistic daughter Pyper. The town sees them as advertising for the family's adjacent restaurant, the Omelette Factory.
According to the lawsuit, the enforcement violates the LeBlancs' First Amendment rights. "The roosters are a symbol of one thing: How much we love our daughter," David LeBlanc said in a statement. "But the town made up an entirely different meaning for them."
The town's own accommodations ran into the family's own logic. Ogunquit granted a disability variance allowing two roosters — on the condition they be attached to a railing. The LeBlancs declined to build one and chained the statues to posts instead. More fines followed, and the family has since removed all the tin birds. Many of the original roosters have since been adopted by local residents and businesses, and supporters around the world have been buying their own rooster statues to display. "Every time Pyper spots another rooster in someone's yard, her face lights up," Sara LeBlanc said.
The suit notes that other local businesses display lobster buoys, antique farm equipment and large tiki statues without incurring fines. "This is governmental discrimination based on the content of speech and the identity of the speaker," the complaint reads. "Such discrimination is presumptively unconstitutional, and the Town cannot justify it." Ogunquit's town clerk, Christine Murphy, did not respond to a request for comment.
The LeBlancs are represented by the Institute for Justice, which won a similar case in New Hampshire in 2025, when a judge sided with a bakery owner in a dispute with the town of Conway over a large mural — painted by high school students, featuring doughnuts — that the town had classified as a regulated sign. The judge found the town had infringed the owner's free speech rights.
The pattern in both cases is the same: a municipal code written for commercial signage, applied by officials who never bear the cost of the paperwork they generate, against a family or small business that pays full price for standing its ground.