North America

Harvard students unveil counter-designs to Trump's 250-foot triumphal arch, reflecting pool and cobblestone axis would keep Memorial Circle open

Judge extends construction ban until at least December 3

Images

Simulation images of the two-fountain detail design for a D.C. memorial. Simulation images of the two-fountain detail design for a D.C. memorial. newsweek.com
newsweek.com
newsweek.com
newsweek.com

Two Harvard landscape architecture students have unveiled alternative designs for Memorial Circle in Washington, where the Trump administration intends to raise a 250-foot triumphal arch between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery. The proposals — a circular reflecting pool and a cobblestone route flanked by low fountains — were developed with the Cultural Landscape Foundation as what its authors call a "speculative counter proposal." U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, meanwhile, extended by 14 days the order keeping the administration from breaking ground, pushing any construction past December 3.

The arch has drawn opposition from Washington advocacy groups, veterans and their families. An analysis found that more than 75,000 graves in the National Cemetery would be overshadowed over the course of a year, and members of the Kennedy family have called the plans a "permanent denigration" of their relatives' grave sites. President Trump has promised "the greatest and most beautiful triumphal arch, anywhere in the world."

The students, Jeremy Dvorak and Jake Geitner, developed the designs in a course taught by the foundation's president, Charles Birnbaum. The first places a large circular reflecting pool in Memorial Circle, holding to the visual axis that runs from the Lincoln Memorial across Arlington Memorial Bridge and down Memorial Avenue to the cemetery; because it stays close to the ground, the foundation says, it would leave traffic circulation untouched and avoid adverse effects on nearby historic properties. The second keeps the circle's existing form and reorganizes the roads around a central cobblestone route, strengthening the connection from the bridge toward the cemetery, with two low circular fountains on either side. Both keep the circle open and stay near the ground.

Birnbaum presents the work as a correction of method rather than a rival monument. "Unlike the administration, we are listening to the public's concerns — especially those of veterans and Gold Star families," he said, adding that a design working with the landscape's history "is not only possible, but should be explored if this memorial is to truly commemorate the nation's 250th anniversary."

The arch would rise 250 feet over a circle the student designs keep at water level. Of his project, Trump has said: "It's going to be really beautiful. I think it's going to be fantastic."