Politics

West Bengal minister tells critics of police killings to go to Bangladesh

Five accused men dead in alleged gunfights since the party took power in May, Bengali-speakers have already been forced across that border by mistake

Images

West Bengal minister Dilip Ghosh
    
    
       |
    
     Dilip Ghosh, @DilipGhoshBJP/X West Bengal minister Dilip Ghosh | Dilip Ghosh, @DilipGhoshBJP/X scroll.in

A West Bengal minister has defended the killing of crime suspects in alleged police gunfights as "a necessary act to decriminalise a criminalised society" — and told critics who disapprove to leave for Bangladesh, offering to arrange the journey "without a visa". Dilip Ghosh's remarks, reported by TV9 Bangla, followed at least five deaths in alleged police gunfights in the six months since his Bharatiya Janata Party took power in the state in May.

All five were accused men; none had been convicted. On Sunday Ratan Sheikh, accused of shooting and injuring a constable two days earlier, was killed in an alleged gunfight in Birbhum district. On November 9 Dilip Roy, accused of raping and murdering a minor girl, died the same way in Raiganj. On October 28 two more were killed in separate incidents: Prahlad Das, accused of raping and murdering a minor in North 24 Parganas, and Samaul Sheikh, accused of murdering a BJP worker in Murshidabad. In July, Prabhas Mondal, accused of raping and murdering a minor in South 24 Parganas, was shot dead when he allegedly snatched an officer's rifle. Ghosh promised the killings would continue and challenged "anyone who has the guts to try to stop us", adding: "Are bulldozers not being used?" In November 2024 the Supreme Court held punitive demolitions illegal, noting that no provision in Indian law allows the demolition of an accused person's property.

The destination in Ghosh's taunt is not rhetorical. Since the terror attack in Pahalgam in April 2025, police in several BJP-ruled states have detained Bengali-speaking people, mostly Muslims, on suspicion of not being Indian citizens, and several have been forced into Bangladesh after allegedly failing to prove theirs. Ghosh framed the stakes himself: "There was a time when attempts were made to convert West Bengal into Bangladesh. We will turn Bengal into Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat" — states where punitive demolitions against accused people, often Muslims, have become commonplace. He said governments that lack the strength to act "strike deals with criminals" instead, and warned that men harassing women, particularly Hindu women, would meet the fate of the man killed in Birbhum.

In some cases, people forced into Bangladesh were brought back to India only after state authorities proved they were Indian citizens.