Milburn report set to blame Labour's own policies for youth jobs crisis
Findings say minimum wage rises priced least experienced out of work, verdict comes from commission the government itself appointed
Images
Labour IS to blame for the youth job crisis, Milburn report will say
dailymail.com
A report by Alan Milburn will conclude that Labour's own policies have damaged the work prospects of young Britons, the Daily Mail reports — a verdict handed down not by the opposition but by a commission the Labour government itself appointed.
According to the Mail, the report will point to the party's minimum wage rises and higher employment costs as the mechanisms that priced the least experienced workers out of jobs. If that is what it says, it is an unusual document. Governments commission reviews to be told their difficulties are structural, global, inherited, or all three; the standard recommendation is more of whatever the government is already doing. A reviewer who returns an indictment of the paymaster's own record is a rarer artefact.
The economics is the uncomplicated part. A wage floor set above what an inexperienced worker can produce does not transfer money from employers to that worker; it removes the job, because an employer who cannot cover the difference at the mandated price stops offering it. The people affected are precisely those with the least to sell — the young and the inexperienced. No decree raises their output to match the new price. The finding will surprise no one who has run a payroll.
The mechanism is not new; the messenger is. Analyses pointing this way have circulated for years — from opposition benches, employer associations and economists outside the commission system — and each could be dismissed as motivated. The same conclusion, produced by a body the government set up to examine youth unemployment, converts a partisan argument into an official finding. The government now owns both the problem and the diagnosis.
The harder question is what Burnham's government does with its own verdict. Reversing the wage rises means confronting the unions and the membership, who regard the minimum wage as a principle rather than a price. Accepting the findings while changing nothing leaves the young carrying a cost the government now officially knows they are paying — and the report becomes a scheduled embarrassment rather than a policy input. There is a well-documented method for that outcome: publish on a quiet day, praise the rigour of the work, note that circumstances have changed.
The commission was appointed to explain why young people were not finding work. On the Mail's account, its answer is the government that appointed it.