Judge lets DRAM cartel suit against Samsung SK Hynix and Micron reach discovery
Complaint alleges prices rose eightfold as all three cut output then retired DDR4 in step, Ninth Circuit had called the same pattern ordinary oligopoly behavior
Images
zerohedge.com
zerohedge.com
zerohedge.com
A federal judge in San Jose has denied in full a joint motion to dismiss an antitrust class action against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron over DRAM prices, opening the case to discovery. The November 14 order by Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California found the complaint plausibly alleges an agreement in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The defendants must answer by December 7.
The suit, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, was filed on June 25 by 17 plaintiffs from five states — 14 consumers and three small PC builders — seeking class status, an injunction and treble damages on behalf of indirect purchasers, meaning anyone who bought a device containing commodity DRAM. It accuses the three companies of conspiring to choke off supply of conventional DRAM while pivoting capacity to high-bandwidth memory for AI datacenters. The complaint alleges SK Hynix and Micron announced production cuts about three weeks apart, with Samsung following in 2023; that all three then locked HBM capacity in under long-term supply contracts; and that all three announced the wind-down of mainstream DDR4 between April and June 2025. Prices rose eightfold over three years.
In September the defendants argued this was the same conspiracy theory a previous court rejected, wearing an AI wrapper: cutting output and retiring old product lines is what each company does independently under shared market pressure. At the hearing they invoked the late judge Richard Posner's observation that rivals in concentrated markets keep a predator's eye on one another. Wise replied that the alleged conduct is "more akin to hawks flying in formation," noting that hawks do not normally fly in formation. She found the case distinguishable from the near-identical 2018 suit over the 2016-2018 price spike, which was dismissed in 2020 and affirmed by the Ninth Circuit in March 2022 on the ground that simultaneous output cuts looked like ordinary oligopoly behavior.
The industry has form. The complaint recounts the 1998-2002 DRAM cartel, which cost Samsung a $300 million fine and SK Hynix $185 million, while Micron received immunity for blowing the whistle. The current stakes run beyond PC builders: soaring memory prices reached PC shipments in January, producer prices in June and Apple's price list shortly after, and Goldman Sachs estimated in July that AI-driven memory, software and electricity costs would add half a percentage point to core PCE by year-end. Memory prices remain elevated.
Micron's immunity dates from the last cartel. This time it answers alongside the other two, on December 7.